• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

YeinJee's Asian blog

Asian Culture, Lifestyle and Entertainment

UPM vs student over confiscated notebook

November 19, 2007 by Yein Jee

Lee Song Yong, a student in Universiti Putra Malaysia (UPM), is battling with the varsity to get back his notebook that security staff confiscated in August.

UPM on the other hand is seeking disciplinary action against Lee. They may punish him for not cooperating with the staff during the incident.

I don’t like seeing lawyers and politicians meddling in university affairs. But I also hate the lack of clarity with local varsities when handling various issues.

Security check

I’m a graduate of local university. Security check was part of life especially after night. The intention, at least on paper, was alright. It’s a safety net to protect university properties and students who stayed in campus dormitories.

However, do universities expect students to just hand over their belongings when told to do so? Especially expensive stuff like mobile phones and laptops.

And do universities have enough reasons to seize personal properties? Do they have any authority to do so under Malaysian law to begin with?

It’s common to have student IDs checked, but me and my friends never had belongings seized during my days. And frankly if I was in Lee’s shoes I would ask lots of questions and require the personnel to show cause too.

Politics & education

Politics and education don’t mix in Malaysia. It sounds ridiculous but undergraduates in Malaysian universities are not allowed to actively involved in politics. And that’s despite the fact that many of them are old enough to vote in general election.

UPM didn’t mention this boldly but Lee was probably targeted for political reasons. Judging from how he’s fighting the case he’s probably involved in politics instead. I mean, student getting help from lawyer over petty issue? Come on.

However, it’s not a good enough reason to seize the notebook and hold it for months. Furthermore UPM didn’t find anything wrong inside the computer. There are no probable cause for all these to happen, and they are clearly in the wrong.

Update 2008

Lee was initially suspended for one semester for “obstructing campus officers from performing their duty.” The sentence was reduced to a RM200 fine after an appeal in January 2008. Justified or not it’s probably wise to accept the deal.

Although it’s probably within their rights to issue punishment, shouldn’t UPM apologise for making a mistake at the first place? Guess that’s not happening.

Filed Under: Malaysian Politics Tagged With: Education culture, Malaysia blog, Universiti Putra

Primary Sidebar

About

Yein Jee is a Malaysian traveller, food lover & self proclaimed entrepreneur. This blog is about Asian culture, lifestyle, travel, food, fun and entertainment ... Read More...

Footer

Latest Personal Posts

Happy CNY 2019 and Good Health

Happy Chinese New Year and Happy Lunar New Year. Traditional CNY greetings are usually about wealth and prosperity, but I prefer to wish everyone good health … [Read More...] about Happy CNY 2019 and Good Health

The journey so far, going forward, and rebuilding the blog

This will be the final year of my 30's. Time flies, and it seems to fade faster as one gets older. This post is a bit of recap of my adult life and some future … [Read More...] about The journey so far, going forward, and rebuilding the blog

ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Entertainment Posts

Top Gun: Maverick movie trailer is beautiful

Trailer for American film Top Gun: Maverick, a sequel to 1986's Top Gun. Beautiful is not the usual word to associate with action movies, but I cannot find a better … [Read More...] about Top Gun: Maverick movie trailer is beautiful

Godzilla: King of the Monsters movie trailer

Trailer for American monster film Godzilla: King of the Monsters. Directed by Michael Dougherty and stars Kyle Chandler, Vera Farmiga, Millie Bobby Brown, Bradley … [Read More...] about Godzilla: King of the Monsters movie trailer

Latest General Posts

Malaysia Covid-19 lockdown – Thank you, stay safe, good luck

Malaysia will be in lockdown from March 18 to March 31, 2020, to deal with the Covid-19 situation. Officially it's a Movement Control Order (MCO) but it's … [Read More...] about Malaysia Covid-19 lockdown – Thank you, stay safe, good luck

Kpop idol Sulli found dead, apparent suicide

Korean pop idol Sulli, former member of girl group f(x), was found dead at her home on Monday. Authorities are investigating the cause of death, and it's presumed … [Read More...] about Kpop idol Sulli found dead, apparent suicide

Latest Offbeat Posts

Singapore queued for last bubble tea before tightened lockdown

Singapore has imposed the circuit breaker measures to curb the spread of Covid-19 since early April. They announced an extension (until June 1) and some new rules a … [Read More...] about Singapore queued for last bubble tea before tightened lockdown

An Officer and a Gentle Cat

A cute photo series amidst the Covid-19 lockdown in Malaysia. Armed forces are present to assist the police to enforce the Movement Control Order (MCO) across the … [Read More...] about An Officer and a Gentle Cat

Home - About/Contact - Terms/Privacy

  • Latest
  • Lifestyle
  • Entertainment
  • Offbeat
  • General
  • About/Contact